Rakes Rogues and Romance

Where your guilty pleasure is only a chapter away

How Do I (Not) Love Thee-Let Me Count The Ways

| 18 Comments

Hi everyone…I’m Baaaack!

It was a lovely week in Cancun, Mexico, but now it’s back to the day job, the 30 degree weather and reality. (You mean no room service-no pool bar in my apartment?  Damn.)

Now, several things happened while I was on vacation, the most significant of them being that my husband broke my Kindle.  Yes.  you heard correct. Broke. My. Kindle.  It was a tough decision but I allowed him to remain breathing (there was a debate about that).

He also has a hard time sleeping while on vacation, and tends to snore.  Loudly. Now, you may ask, “Why in God’s name does she need to tel us that?”  Well, it is because when he would snore, Nancy couldn’t sleep.  And when Nancy couldn’t sleep, she would lay in bed and run scenes for my WIP in my head.  And one morning,  (it was 4:20 am), an entire re-write of the first scene for my first WIP just popped into my head.  I got out of bed and typed it all out.  and I love it.

When I first decided to try my hand at writing, I, being an internet groupie, did a Google search for Romance Writing groups.  I joined one and saw that there were critique groups.  I had written quite a few chapters and I submitted my first.

A whole new world of language opened up to me: Headhopping, POV, Info Dump, Dialogue Tags, etc.  Other writers would go through my work and make suggestions, some of which were very helpful.

But then there were the other comments that were downright mean.  Nasty.  Comments for the sole purpose of demoralizing a person.  I’m not a baby, and I don’t need my criticism sugar coated but there is a way to say things that is constructive and a way to say things that is nasty.  I thought, “What’s up with that?”  Is that the way to help someone who is first starting out?  Not in my book. Literally and figuratively.  So I left that group and haven’t been back.

It was the best thing I ever did.

The art of critiquing and being critiqued is a fine dance between people who are virtually strangers, and whose only common denominator is their written word.  When you enter a critique group, you must first critique someone and then they will “crit”  your work.  You put in your baby, your written words that you think are so perfect, and watch it come back with red lines, deletes and examples of how much better your work can be.

I now belong to several romance writing forums and several critique groups.  For all the other writers out there,  I may be wrong, but receiving back a critique from a fellow writer can be one of the scariest emails to open. Will they like it?  Do I have a story line?  Can I actually write?  Writing Regency Romance is challenging, as there are so many differences in language, social strictures and other issues that require knowledge of the time period, so I was thrilled to find several forums where there are people who specifically write in that genre.  People who understand and are helpful with their comments and critiques

I am back to writing and re-writing my first WIP, The Duke’s Frozen Heart (and back to the name for now at least), but I hadn’t submitted it for a critique for quite a while.  Once I re-wrote that scene and felt so much better about the first chapter, I decided to submit it.

The critiques showed knowledge of the genre, knowledge of writing and viable improvements to the story that will make it so much better.  I cannot say how much I appreciate these wonderful writers who take the time out of their busy schedules to critique other people’s work, my work included with their thoughtful incisive comments and suggestions.

So this is my thank you to all the wonderful authors at Regency Romance Critiquers,  Rom-Critters and FTH Critiquers for all the help you have given me.  I can only hope my critiques have helped you, and that we can all cheer each other on to publication.

Have you, as a writer, ever experienced negative feedback that caused you to have second thoughts as to continuing on?

18 thoughts on “How Do I (Not) Love Thee-Let Me Count The Ways

  1. Excellent Post Nancy! Having a good critique group you can trust is so important. I’m happy you’re part of ours. We love reading your stuff and can’t wait to read more! You are talented my friend! *Hugs

  2. Finding the write (pun intended) group is paramount. I’m blessed by a longtime group, Crit-Me, and then some one on ones–Jenn, Sheri, Kristi, Sara, Allie, who are incredible. An in-town group put me on the ground for almost a year. Never again.

  3. Great overall assessment of critique groups–thanks for posting!

  4. I agree with you, Nancy. There is a right and a wrong way to crit. I’ve also had my share of mean critique partners, and believe me, I didn’t stick around them for very long! Good blog!

  5. Great post. Hope you get a new kindle and sometimes it takes a thick skin to read a crit.

  6. I guess I have a pretty thick skin. My first crit said that my story was weak, my heroine was “confusing and wierd” I had too much passive voice and too much author intrusion. I still refer back to that crit. I’ve even used some of the wording in crits I’ve given. I revised that story at least seven times before I sold it. I just today finished my 3rd round of edits and it will be released this year. I personally don’t prefer cheerleader crits. In fact, to receive a crit back with no comments is insulting to me. It’s like the person didn’t care at all, they just wanted an easy way for someone to crit them. I usually spend anywhere from an hour to three hours on every chapter crit I do, and I do that because I have a genuine desire to help. I take every opinion into account because, like you said, someone took the time. I don’t always agree with their accessment, but I do consider it. In that vein, I am not an easy critter and I try to warn people of that upfront. I give my honest opinion, what I think I know to make the story work better. I always make it clear that, good or bad, it is only my opinion.

    Thanks for the post.

  7. Great post, Nancy. Mean critiques are horrible. I’m glad you’ve found CPs who help you. It’s a learning process we all go through. You’re stories are wonderful. I tweeted.

  8. Good to have you back Nancy. I didn’t expect you to have time to write. I recall my day of returning to work. By noon I regretted taking my vacation due to all the crap that got dumped at my door while I was away. “Oh Liza isn’t here to object, let’s give it to her to do.’

    Good to have you back. I hope you can still retain vacation mems. Sorry about the Kindle. I assume he will replace it with the latest model.

    Re snoring. My prior SO snored so loud that one night I considered suffocating him with my pillow. Seriously considered it. Can’t speak for him, but that scared the willies out of me. Sleep deprivation can make you crazy.

    Liza, who shares way too much.

  9. My first critique group had one lady in it who was just vicious – she let loose on a 1/2 page rant because of a joke between 2 of my characters. The joke wasn’t bigoted, or obscene. If I had a misspelled word – stand back and duck – I’m Canadian – we spell words differently. I had no idea that there were nice critique groups out there – I put up with it for a while and then quit – quit writing – quit everything. To this day, when I open crits or edits – my blood pressure rises, my heart pounds.
    Someday I’d like to find that lady and give her sh*t!.

    Good post. Hope you future Kindle is awesome. :-)

  10. I was fortunate to find RomCritters when I sought a critique group. First one I chose, and it’s been great for me. I’ve met such wonderful, talented writers there.

  11. This was great! My husband is my best and worst critic. I told him he was the meanest editor I ever had. All in fun of course. I value his opinion, but it scares me every time he reads my work.

  12. Loved this post, Nancy! Glad you were able to get some writing time in while on vacay!! I’m with you…people don’t have to be nasty when they crit. The industry is so tough to break into that we writers have to stick together. Support each other. That’s just the right thing to do. :) Thanks for sharing!

  13. Lovely post! Beautiful blog! Way to go, ladies!
    -R.T. Wolfe

  14. Nancy,
    I hear you, both from the can’t sleep due to snoring, and the nasty critique comments. My current critique partners are fabulous, but I experienced profoundly snarky, vicious comments from contest judges. Truth is one thing; but demoralizing. . . not okay.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

Follow

Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.

Join 1,461 other followers